Women in Antiquity
Course Info
Assignments
Content
Resources
Return to schedule of responses
Topic: Living Unpublicly in Classical Athens
Due: Sun Oct 26
Prompt: What do this week’s primary source readings tell us about how Athenians saw the contrast in genders?
The documents for this week are:
For your online response this week, write a post that includes the following:
- What passage or detail in particular jumped out at you as you read through it?
- What do you think the author was trying to communicate?
- In your opinion, what is this document telling us about the time and place it comes from?
- What about this document seems to relate to, support, or even contradict our other readings about this time and place?
- What would you like to find out more about?
Responses for Week 7
Response for Week 7
Mark Wilson
1784
2025-10-20 17:59:14
Hey folks! This week we’re looking at The Bacchae and scenes from the Adonis Festival. How do you read the assertive actions of the women in these two vividly told tales? What do you think the contrasts between genders in these readings tell us about the intent of the authors involved?
Week 7 Response
Kenneth Esteras
1827
2025-10-29 10:19:02
What stood out to me the most was the conversation between Gorgo and Praxinoa as they prepared for the Adonis Festival. Their dialogue feels so relatable and real – they talk about crowds, long walks, and even annoying neighbors. It gave me a new way to see ancient Greek women, not as distant or voiceless figures, but as real people with humor, opinions, and everyday struggles. I feel Theocritus wanted to show that women, too, had voices and experiences worth noticing. Through their talk, he reveals how festivals allowed women to step outside their homes, connect with each other, and take part in a community life. It's a small but powerful look into their world. The reading shows that even though ancient Greek society limited women in many ways, they still found space for expression and independence in social and religious settings. I'd like to learn more about how the Adonis Festival reflected ideas about love. beauty, and loss – and what it meant for women’s identities in that time.
Response for Week 7
Eric Lezama
1818
2025-10-28 01:10:42
While reading The Bacchae, the part of the passage that jumped out to me the most was when Pentheus dresses as a female worshipper. I found this interesting because it flips the usual power dynamic between men and women. Pentheus is a figure of authority and logic, traits that are associated with masculinity yet they are willing to make light of his gender by dressing him as a women. I believe the author was trying to provide commentary on the relationship of men and women that is meant to question gender roles.
Response week 7
Ammie Ocampo
1812
2025-10-26 23:26:11
The passage that resonated with me the most originates from The Bacchae written by Euripides. Driven by curiosity, King Pentheus wanted to witness the women’s divine frenzy and went to where they were. He goes so far as to disguise himself as a woman to observe them. In their madness, the women think King Pentheus is a lion and they go after him. He ultimately meets his death when the women, led by the king’s mother, kills him by “tearing him limb by limb”. While there are many messages in the passage, I believe the author symbolizes Dionysus as an unstoppable power- affiliated with nature representing irrationality and liberation from the expected standards. Dionysus is also the God of wine – which I believe amplifies chaos and unreasonableness. On the other hand, King Pentheus represents the established order and the reasoning that supports. Although King Pentheus is initially irritated and refuses to accept Dionysus, I believe the author highlights Pentheus’s failure the moment he disguises himself as a woman.
In my opinion, the author aims to show the significant impact women could have if they lived outside the social structure of this historical period. I also believe that the author expresses the importance of a woman’s role in her family during this setting. Agave refused to believe that her sister had given birth to a divine child, and her family ultimately suffered the consequences. It indicates that during this time, the effects of actions extended beyond the individual to the whole family. I also think the author is demonstrating that too much logic or too much chaos can result in ruin. The middle path between reason and madness is where balance lives. Another work that explores balance between extremes is Aeschylus’s Eumenides. Both passages share similarities, such as the conflict between the old order and the new order. The furies have old standing structure and act with immediate madness after Orestes kills his mother. Apollo immediately defends Orestes, providing justification for his innocence. The middle path comes from Athena – providing a civilized form where both parties can explain their justification. I am curious about how audiences at the time reacted to the play. Would audiences have viewed Pentheus’ cross-dressing as worse than a mother killing her child? How did the women respond to the play’s climax? Did society believe that women exposed to nature would inevitably make them act irrationally?
The Bacchae / Euripides
Sherling Urena
1808
2025-10-26 21:54:16
What stood out to me was when the messenger characterizes the women in the mountains, "with bare hands they tore apart lowing calves, while others held the dripping flesh and hung it on the firs." I found this moment particularly noteworthy in that it portrays women acting with an untamed wildness and frenzy outside the domestic sphere expected of them in Greek society.
I think the author is demonstrating the strength and danger of denying a god like Dionysus, since the ability for women to act in frenzy demonstrates the control that divine forces assume when they are respected or not. The frenzy can be interpreted as a warning or a demonstration of the control that gods have over human life and society.
This text tells us that religion was central to Classical Greece in shaping the framework for understanding power, gender, and nature. The women were depicted in a connection to an untamed space of ecstatic ritual, as contrary to the order of the male-dominant city. This demonstrates the fear and reverence for the power of the gods as guiding behavior and identity.
This can also relate to other textual evidence that focuses on the dangers of hubris and the importance of honoring a god. However, this text is a departure and complicates the portrayal of women as passive. Here, women are engaged and powerful. I would like to know more about how actual Greek audiences responded to the storytelling in literature like this.
Homework
Antoine Julien
1796
2025-10-26 16:47:39
One striking detail that I found was the graphic and gruesome description of the dismemberment of Pentheus by his mother, Agave, and the Bacchae. Imagery such as tearing apart limbs and hunting for lions, as well as the transformation of characters Cadmus and Harmonia into serpents, emphasizes much of the chaos and divine retribution that is central to the play. Further enriched by an intricate account of divine origin and travel from Asia into Greece is Dionysus, whom he considers to have legitimate authority as a god. Euripides perhaps additionally suggests the dangers of hubris, that is, an excessive pride or disrespect to the gods, as well as stressing the importance of respecting divine authority. Divine vengeance, madness, and the risks of their denial or insult are themes central to the play. God's often harsh judgments are justified, and more often than not, human pride ends in ruin. This play speaks to ancient Greek values and religious beliefs, particularly the consideration that rites before the deities are critical and that impiety leads to destruction. It pictures a society where gods are actively involved in human affairs such that dishonoring them is tantamount to war, leading to chaos and tragedies. The play also speaks of purviews that view heavenly punishment as a natural consequence of breaking sacred customs by humans, thus reinforcing the importance of piety and reverence in Greek society. The play merits stressing Greek classical culture on piety and the consequences of hubris. Those intense punishments appear rather consistent with the Greek belief that the gods demand respect, with their wrath being severe upon those who defy them. However, a more complicated view of divine justice is revealed, because Dionysus's vengeance is harsh and arguably excessive. The play argues something of a critique or reflection of human fears about divine caprice. This tension thus seems likely to rebel against the idealized perception of divine justice, in suggesting that the visible assertion of the gods' right to hold humanity accountable can also be overly harsh.
Women at the Adonis Festival
Rawan Mustafa
1793
2025-10-26 13:13:27
The part that really caught my attention was when Gorgo and Praxinoa were walking through the busy streets trying to reach the festival. Their conversation felt so real and funny
especially when they complained about their husbands and the chaos around them. It honestly reminded me of how friends talk today when they go out together. It made these ancient women feel alive and relatable, not just distant figures from history.
I think Theocritus wanted to show that women in his time had their own personalities, opinions, and humor, even though society often ignored them. Through their talk, he gives us a peek into the daily lives of regular women — their frustrations, friendships, and the way they balanced home life with public events.
This piece tells us a lot about Alexandria during that period. It seems like a lively, crowded, and diverse city where people from different places mixed together. It also shows that women could take part in festivals and social gatherings, even if their roles were still limited.
Compared to other readings about ancient Greece, this one feels more down-to-earth. Most texts focus on Gods and Goddesses , but this one focuses on everyday life and simple human experiences. It’s refreshing to see that side of history.
I’d love to learn more about what the Adonis Festival meant for women at that time — whether it was more of a religious event or a rare chance for them to enjoy some freedom and social connection.
Week 7
Dinarsha Thapa
1791
2025-10-25 00:21:11
The detail that particularly interested me was from “The Bacchae”. Dionysus transforms himself into a human and punishes the women who spread false rumors about his mother and father. The readings also show that Dionysus wants everyone to believe he is a god and worship him. Pentheus, who refuses to allow people to worship him, becomes his target. Dionysus takes human form to correct the situation and demonstrate his divinity. This passage conveys the message that when a god sees something they don’t like, they may intervene in different ways to set things right. This document also supports other readings because it demonstrates how humans are punished for their behaviors that anger the gods. I would like to find out why gods often use death as punishment. Why don’t they use other ways to help people realize their mistakes instead of killing them?
Week 7
Perla Castillo
1789
2025-10-24 08:24:43
One part of The Bacchae that really struck me was when Dionysus punished the women of Thebes by causing them to go mad and flee to the mountains. I was shocked because it showed how strong and terrifying the gods could be when people disrespected them. I think the author wanted to show that ignoring or mocking a god could lead to terrible things. It also showed that women, who usually led quiet lives, could suddenly act freely and wildly when controlled by a god. It made me think that perhaps their madness was also a way for them to break free from their normal lives.
In Women at the Festival of Adonis, I noticed that the women were happy to get out of the house and go to the festival. They talked a lot, joked, and complained about their husbands while admiring the decorations. The author portrayed them as fun-loving and curious about life. This tells us that in Alexandria, women sometimes enjoyed and participated in public celebrations, although most often they stayed home. Compared to The Bacchae, this story seems lighter, but both show that women could unite through religion and festivals.